What should I choose between Natural or lab diamond?

Your friendly guide to picking the stone that truly fits you.

Choosing a diamond isn’t just about sparkle — it’s about finding the stone that matches your style, values, and budget. Whether you’re leaning towards a natural diamond or a lab-grown one, both can be beautiful, meaningful, and long-lasting. Here’s a clear, down-to-earth breakdown to help you decide.

1. What’s the Real Difference?

Natural diamonds are formed deep in the earth over billions of years.

Lab-grown diamonds are created in a highly controlled environment using advanced technology.

The key thing: they’re both real diamonds.

Same chemical structure. Same brilliance. Same strength (10/10 on the Mohs scale).

2. Price: Where Most Couples Start

If you want maximum size and sparkle without blowing the budget, lab-grown diamonds are a smart choice.

You can often get a bigger, higher-quality stone for 40–70% less than natural.

If the idea of rarity and long-term value matters to you, natural diamonds hold their price better over time.

3. Appearance: Do They Look Different?

To the naked eye? No.

Even gemologists need specialised equipment to tell them apart.

Both can be colourless, bright, and cut to perfection. What matters more is the cut quality — the factor that gives a diamond its fire and sparkle.

4. Values & Meaning: What Feels Right for You?

Some couples love the romance and history behind natural diamonds.

Others prefer the modern, ethical, and sustainable feel of lab-grown.

Neither is wrong — it’s about what fits your story.

5. Certification: Always Check the Paperwork

No matter what you choose, make sure it comes with a real grading certificate from IGI or GIA.

This protects you and guarantees the diamond’s quality.

At Humphrey Jewellery, both lab and natural diamonds include full certification — so you know exactly what you’re getting.

6. Durability & Everyday Wear

Good news:

Both natural and lab diamonds last a lifetime.

They don’t scratch. They don’t cloud. They don’t lose sparkle.

Choose based on the lifestyle and look you love — not fear of durability.

7. So… Which One Should You Choose?

Here’s a simple way to decide:

Choose

Lab-Grown

if you want:

• Bigger size for your budget

• Higher clarity or colour without overspending

• A modern, ethical, sustainable option

• A statement look at an affordable price

explore our collection

Choose

Natural

if you want:

• Rarity and long-term value

• A stone formed naturally over billions of years

• A more traditional engagement ring story

• Something that holds its resale value more strongly

Final Thoughts

There’s no “better” option — just the one that feels right for you.

Both natural and lab-grown diamonds can be breathtaking. Both can symbolise love beautifully.

If you’re still unsure, we’re always happy to guide you, show comparisons, or help you find the perfect diamond that fits your vision.

Message us anytime here or 0478119591 — we reply quickly and genuinely love helping couples choose their dream ring. 🤍💍